56 – Predator: The deaths of Patricia McGauley and Mary Cummins

1990 was a decade of missing women. We remember the names of the unfound – Annie McCarrick, Eva Brennan, Jo Jo Dollard, Deirdre Jacob.

The names Patricia McGauley and Mary Cummins were once on that list. These two women disappeared from Dublin in the space of a year, and it wasn’t until a large scale review of cases of missing women from Dublin that a startling link was discovered between the two women. Both of them had unknowingly spent time with a predator: Michael Bambrick.

With thanks to today’s sponsor thebouqs.com. Go to thebouqs.com/mensand enter code MENS at checkout for 25% off your order of farm fresh flowers!

Don’t forget to check out our sponsors Best Fiends, the 5* rated puzzle game. Find it on the Apple App store and Google Play

Find us on Facebook or Twitter!

With thanks to our supporters on Patreon! Donate today to get access to bonus and ad-free episodes!

Our featured podcast this week is from our good friends over at Murderific! Get ready to hear  true stories about serial killers, mass murders, the missing, and unsolved crimes. Listen here! 

Theme Music:

Quinn’s Song: The Dance Begins Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

Additional Music:   Allemande (Sting) by Wahneta Meixsell. Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/

Sources:

Stephen Rae, Killers:Murders in Ireland (Dublin: Blackwater Press, 1998) p.p. 67 – 80.

“Murder accused seeks early trial” in TheIrishTimes (8 December 1995) p. 4.   
Bernard Condon BL, “Life sentence not available where  manslaughter plea is accepted by DPP” in The Irish Times (7 October 1996) p 20.   

“Remand in double murder case” in The Irish Times (27 October 1995) p. 4.   

“Man faces charges in 2 murders” in The Irish Times (21 October 1995) p. 4. 

“Man admits manslaughter of two women discovered by Garda dig” in The Irish Times (4 May 1996) 

“Garda evidence leaked to media before case was proven in court” in The Irish Times (25 July 1996) p. 4.   

“Bambrick admits  women died when he gagged them during intercourse” in The Irish Times (18 July 1996) p. 4 

Jim Cusack, “Disappearances occurred during a most violent period” in The Irish Times (11 September 2001) p. 9.   

Jim Cusack, “Missing women believed buried in the Dublin area” in The Irish Times , (20 May 1995) p. 7.   

Marie O’Halloran, “Missing woman’s sister believes she is dead” in The Irish Times (14 April 1995) p. 6.   

Jim Cusack, “Arrested man brought gardai to locations of women’s bodies” in The Irish Times (27 June 1995) p. 1.   

“Forensic tests on women’s bodies” in The Irish Times (1 July 1995) p. 4. 

“Charges in murder cases expected” in The Irish Times (20 October 1995) p. 6.   

“Double sex killer gets 18-year jail sentence” in The Irish Times (27 July 1996) p. 6.   

Frank Kilfeather and Jim Cusack, “Skull found at Garda dig after arrest over alleged sexual assaults” in The Irish Times (26 June 1995) p. 1.   

Jim Cusack, “Serial killer theory gains ground,” in The Irish Independent (26 September 1998) p. 9. 

Jim Cusack, “Garda search on site for body continues” in The Irish Times (28 June 1995) p. 3.    

Jim Cusack, “Murdered women were dismembered, say gardai” in The Irish Independent (30 June 1995) p. 1.   

Jim Cusack, “Gardai find bones at Balgaddy as search for woman continues” in The Irish Times (29 June 1995) p. 1.   

“Killing and dismembering of two women described” in The Irish Times (20 November 1998) p. 6.   

Mairead Carey, “Relatives of Bambrick victim angry at sentence” in The Irish Times  27 July 1996) p. 8.   

“Unrelated case led gardai to connect killings” in The Irish Times (27 July 1996) p. 8.   

Mairead Carey, “Neighbours convinced ‘weird’ man was killer” in The Irish Times (27 July 1996) p. 8.   

Mairead Carey, “Samantha says a prayer every night for Mary” in The Irish Times (27 July 1996) p. 8.   

Mairead Carey, “Double tragedy for family left to bury second daughter” in The Irish Times  ( 27 July 1996) p. 8.   

Jim Cusack, “Arrested man brought gardai to dig sites” in The Irish Times (27 June 1995) p. 3.   

Jim Cusack, “Garda checks found one man linked to two missing women” in The Irish Times (27 June 1995) p. 3.   

“Garda hunt for bodies of missing women moves to new site” in The Irish Times (17 April 1995) p. 1.   

Jim Cusack, “Dig follows major murder investigation” in The Irish Times (26 June 1995) p. 5.  

Fergus Black, “Brutal sex killer freed after 13 years in jail for double slaying” in The Irish Independent https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/courts/brutal-sex-killer-freed-after-13-years-in-jail-for-double-slaying-26531245.html (25 April 2009)   

Allison Bray, “Family outraged over early release of sex killer” in The Irish Independent https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/family-outraged-over-early-release-of-sex-killer-26529103.html (17 April 2009)   

Ben Quinn, “Butchered and buried” in The Irish Independent https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/butchered-and-buried-26168988.html (20 November 1998)  

“Family fury as sex killer freed five years early” in The Evening Herald https://www.herald.ie/news/family-fury-as-sex-killer-freed-five-years-early-27908651.html (17 April 2009)   

Stephen Breen, “Sadistic cross-dressing sex killer Michael Bambrick living under new name in Dublin” in The Irish Sun https://www.thesun.ie/archives/irish-news/232236/sadistic-cross-dressing-sex-killer-michael-bambrick-living-under-new-name-in-dublin/ (8 October 2016)  

Alana Fearson, “Notorious double sex killer Michael Bambrick living in north inner city under new identity” from DublinLive.ie https://www.dublinlive.ie/news/dublin-news/notorious-double-sex-killer-michael-11999244 (9 October 2016)