In June of 1991, 21 year old newly-wed Alison Shaughnessy was found lying in a pool of blood at the entrance to her flat in London by her husband John. After a stalled police investigation, two women were arrested and tried for Alison’s murder.
But is it possible that what was presented to the court as motive for her murder, gleaned from a 21 year old woman’s diary, had pointed police in the wrong direction?
Who killed Alison Shaughnessy?
Find us on Facebook or Twitter!
With thanks to our supporters on Patreon! Donate today to get access to bonus and ad-free episodes!
Check out the Mens Rea Merch Store!
Theme Music:
Quinn’s Song: The Dance Begins Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
Additional Music: Allemande (Sting) by Wahneta Meixsell. Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
Music:
Kevin McLeod, Quinns Song : The Dance Begins. (incompetech.com) Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 3.0 License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/
Sources:
“Irish girl murdered in London” in The Evening Herald(5 June 1991) p. 57
Aidan Hennigan, “Murder to be reconstructed”, in The Evening Press (5 June 1991) p. 5
Bernard Purcell, “Knife killer ‘was waiting for Alison’” in The Evening Herald (5 June 1991) p. 10
“Young wife slain in flat” in The Irish Independent(5 June 1991) p. 1
“Killer’s face ‘scratched’” in The Evening Herald (6 June 1991) p. 2.
“London murder shock” in The Munster Express (7 June 1991) p. 13
‘Late Mrs A Shaughnessy” in The Roscommon Herald (21 June 191) p. 10
Feargal Keane, “Alison a serial killing?” in The Evening Press (24 June 1991) p. 1
“Alison: £25,000 reward” in The Irish Independent (30 July 1991) p. 3
“Alison breakthrough” in The Evening Herald (8 August 1991) p. 19
“Sisters charged with girl’s murder” in The Kilkenny People (16 August 1991) p. 1.
“Sisters remanded for murder” in The Irish Independent(10 august 1991) p 3
“Refused Bail” in The Munster Express (13 September 1991) p. 12
‘Alison killing: man bailed” in The Irish Independent(8 November 1991) p. 24
“Sisters charged with bank clerk’s murder” in The Munster Express (13 December 1991) p. 1.
“Sisters ‘cut throat’ of lover’s Irish wife” in The Irish Independent (28 January 1992) p. 43.
“Piltown Bride’s murder trial” in The Munster Express (31 January 1992) p. 1.
“Jealous lover murdered wife” in The Evening Herald(6 July 1992) p. 57.
“Young bride was stabbed 54 times by her killer” in The Irish Press (7 July 1992) p. 10
“Mistress ‘knifed’ wife 54 times” in The Irish Independent (7 July 1992) p. 3.
“Lover tried to resume affair ‘weeks after stabbing wife death’” in The Irish Press (8 July 1992) p. 3.
“Courtroom tears” in The Irish Independent (8 July 1992) p.p. 1, 13
“I did not murder Alison: husband” in The Evening Herald (8 July 1992) p. 4
“Women seen jogging from murder scene” in The Evening Herald (9 July 1992) p. 4
“Women were seen running from Alison’s home” in The Evening Press (9 January 1992) p. 7
Joe Wood, “Tragic infatuation” in The Irish Independent (10 July 1992) p. 5.
“Bankcard may be key in death alibi” in The Evening Herald (10 July 1992) p. 4.
“Lover was hysterical on seeing body” in The Evening Herald (10 July 1992) p. 4
“Michelle ran to pub screaming” in The Evening Press (10 July 1992) p. 4.
“Mistress hears of frenzied attack that killed wife” in The Irish Pres (10 July 1992) p 1, 3
“London murder trial” in The Muster Express (10 July 1992) p. 1, 16
“Accused girl ‘hysterical’ when she found body” in The Irish Press (11 July 1992) p. 5
Pat Clarke and Peter Anderson, “Alison’s killer did not break into flat” in The Evening Press (13 July 1992) p. 6
“Intimate diary record of murder trial mistress” in The Irish Examiner (14 July 1992) p. 7.
“Alison’s love rival ‘knew affair had no future’” in The Irish Independent (14 July 1992) p. 3.
“Sick’ Alison birthday song” in The Evening Press (14 July 1992) p. 3.
“Alison almost caught husband having sex” in The Evening Herald (14 July 1992) p. 4.
“Mistress was unhappy at ‘ being used’ by boyfriend” in The Irish Press (15 July 1992) p. 5.
“Alison killing: friend’s ‘nightmare living with lie’” in The Irish Independent (16 July 1992) p. 6
“Alison trial is told of ‘false alibi’” in The Irish Press (16 July 1992) p. 12.
“Murder accused ‘went pure white’” in The Irish Press (17 July 1992) p. 4.
“Sisters’ fingerprints found inside death flat” in The Irish Independent (17 July 1992) p. 11
“No evidence to pin death on girls: cop” in The Evening Herald (17 July 1992) p. 4
“’No links’ to Alison murder” in The Irish Independent (18 July 1992) p. 10
“I slept with John on day of his wedding” in The Evening Herald (20 July 1992) p. 4
“’Fantasy’ danger cited to Alison jury” in The Evening Herald (20 July 1992) p. 4
“Mistress ‘slept with husband of Alison on eve of wedding’” in The Irish Press (21 July 1992) p. 6
“Girl joins groom on wedding day” in The Irish Independent (21 July 1992) p. 5.
“I hated Alison: accused” in The Evening Herald (21 July 1992) p. 4.
“Alison ‘alibi’ strengthened” in The Evening Herald (22 July 1992) p. 72
“Murder plan was ‘Michelle’s last despairing act’” in The Irish Independent (23 July 1992) p. 5.
“Intruder killed Alison: defence” in The Evening Press (23 July 1992) p. 28
“Murder trial summing up” in The Irish Press (24 July 1992) p. 2.
“The vital minutes that trapped them” in The Irish Press (25 July 1992) p. 5-7
Aidan Hanigan, “It’s good to see being justice done, says unfaithful husband” in The Irish Press (25 July 1992) p. 6
‘Murder sisters caught out by sinister diaries” in The Irish Press (25 July 1992) p. 6
“Husband a sex-flop say diaries” in The Irish Independent(25 July 1992) p 14
“’Wicked’ sisters plan to appeal conviction” in The Belfast Telegraph (25 July 1992 ) p. 15
“How jury decided mistress became a killer” in The Cork Examiner (25 July 1992) p. 9
“Prison ‘nightmare’ for Taylor sisters” in The Irish Independent (7 August 1992) p. 11
“Jailed pair say trial coverage was unfair” in The Irish Independent (11 August 1992) p. 15
Brendan Purcell, “Alison’s ‘killers’ appeal as new witness is found” in The Evening Herald (14 December 1992) p 59
“Murder case sisters appeal to be heard” in The Cork Examiner (22 April 1993) p. 12
Mary Punch, “Vagrant ‘said he killed Alison’” in The Irish Independent (4 June 1993) p. 3
“Alison parents to quit Britain after appeal” in The Evening Herald (7 June 1993)
“Alison girls in murder appeal” in The Evening Herald(10 June 1993) p. 76
Bernard Purcell, Charles Mallon and Jerome Reilly, “Alison: sisters freed” in The Evening Herald (11 June 1993) p. 1, 4.
Bernard Purcell, “Police ‘kept back Alison evidence’” in The Irish Independent (11 June 1993) p. 8
“Freed on murder charge” in The Evening Echo (11 June 1993) p 38
“Alison murder: sisters are freed” in The Belfast Telegraph (11 June 1993) p. 4
Aidan Hennigan, “O’Shaughnessy case evidence challenged” in The Irish Press (11 June 1993) p. 9
Mairead Carey, “Alison’s husband ‘disgusted’ at verdict” in The Irish Press (12 June 1993) p 1, 4.
“Papers defend press coverage” in The Irish Press (12 June 1993) p. 6
Aidan Hennigan, “Families react with delight and disbelief” in The Irish Press (12 June 1993) p. 5.
“Shaughnessy slams report of girlfriend” in The Irish Press (14 June 1993) p. 10
Marese McDonagh, “Alison’s family rejects ‘male killer’ claim” in The Irish Press (14 June 1993) p. 3
“Alison: sisters’ demand” in The Evening Herald (14 June 1993) p. 10
“PCA launches probe” in The Belfast Telegraph (20 July 1993) P. 6
Michael Conway and Mairead Carey, “Parents of sisters wrongly convicted of Shaughnessy killing speak out” in The Irish Press (18 August 1993) p. 4.
“Alison: No case against police” in The Irish Press (17 November 1994) p 14
John Aston, “Taylor sisters win legal plea over trial coverage” in The Irish Independent (7 December 1994) p. 8
“Alsion case pair sue pal who fought to free them” in The Evening Herald (15 June 1995) p 20
Aileen Hickie, “Stalker on the prowl” in The Irish Independent (16 June 1995) p. 10
“Sisters fail to beat the tabloids” in The Cork Examiner (1 August 1995) p. 24
“High Court sequel to Alison murder trial” in The Munster Express (4 August 1995) p. 1.
“Murder case due lose plea” in The Irish Independent (12 December 1995) p. 8
Tom Reddy, “Murder girl’s family to sue freed sisters” in The Irish Independent (31 July 1997) p 4
“Husband of murdered woman married again” in The Evening Echo (3 August 1998) p. 3.
“Murder case ‘could re-open’” in The Irish Independent (13 March 2001) p. 7
Nicola Anderson, “Now all we want is justice” in The Evening Herald (31 March 2001) p. 4-5
“Eleven years ago Alison O’Shaughnessy was brutally knifed to death. Now her tragic story is to be told again” in The Evening Herald (10 October 2001) p. 29
Larissa Nolan, “My daughter’s killers never to go behind bars” in The Irish Independent https://www.independent.ie/irish-news/my-daughters-killers-never-to-go-behind-bars-26209973.html (26 June 2005)